Best MLB Prop Bets 2025: Today’s Top Betting Props
Major League Baseball betting offers more than just picking winners and losers—it’s about finding value and having fun in the process. And when it comes to creativity and excitement, prop bets are the cream of the crop . Whether you’re a seasoned bettor or just getting started, exploring MLB prop bets opens the door to a whole new level of strategy and entertainment.
That’s why we at MyTopSportsBooks have put together this complete guide to MLB prop bets. From the types of wagers you’ll see to tips on how to build a winning approach, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know to get started. Let’s dive in.
Best MLB Proposition Bets
We’re all here to win, right? Betting is a blast, but the real thrill comes from having skin in the game. That’s why we put in the effort—developing strategies to make the best MLB prop bets we can.
The best MLB player prop bets also demand a different level of research. You might be a sharp bettor in other sports or markets, but that doesn’t automatically translate to success with baseball proposition wagers. These wagers have their own rhythm and require a unique approach.
One thing to keep in mind: no two prop bets are the same. They’re creative by nature. Unlike futures or spreads, you won’t be planning most of these months ahead. You’ll need to stay flexible, keep a few tools handy, and be ready to react when new props drop from the sportsbooks.
That’s why research matters. MLB player and team props require you to go deeper than just knowing the rosters. In many cases, the player becomes the foundation of the bet—not the team. The more intimately you understand both, the better positioned you’ll be.
MLB Prop Bets Picks
But we have good news. You are not in this alone! You can check out MLB prop bets picks by reading our free baseball picks. This is a great way to start to develop your own strategy.
Not only will you get insight into specific bets as they come up. Our experts have been doing this for years, and they will be able to guide you with their picks.
But also, you will start to see how experts think about MLB prop bets. By reading their analysis, you will become familiar with important terms within MLB prop betting, and you will see how betting experts decide which bets to place and when.
Following these baseball prop picks is just one way to get started on making the best MLB prop bets.
MLB All-Star Game Prop Bets
One of the biggest events for prop betting rolled around on July 15, 2025: the MLB All-Star Game. It’s always a fan favorite—and a perfect stage for the kind of creative wagers that make MLB prop bets so exciting.
With such a big audience tuning in every year, the list of prop bets during the MLB All-Star game is always extensive. Here are some examples of different prop bets that you might choose to place in the 2026 All-Star game:
- Home Run Derby: The Home Run Derby usually steals the spotlight during All-Star week. One of the most popular prop bets is picking the winner of the Derby. You can also wager on whether a contestant will hit a home run during the actual All-Star Game.
- Outs: Some props get more specific—like betting on game situations. For example, a prop might ask: “Will there be an out at third base?” These types of wagers add a unique twist to following each play.
- Runs and RBIs: On the flip side, you can also bet on offensive action. Props may include whether a certain player records an RBI, hits a home run, or if the bases will be loaded during a specific inning or at-bat. This year, many bettors may have been tempted to bet on Shohei Ohtani to record at least one RBI during the 2025 All-Star Game, especially given his hot streak leading into the break.
Best MLB Prop Betting Sites
We take time to review and recommend only the best sportsbooks for making MLB prop wagers. These are the three criteria that are the most important when we make our final recommendations of sportsbooks.
Welcome Bonuses
Welcome bonuses are key to having a smooth betting experience. This is especially true when entering the world of baseball proposition wagers. As relatively complicated bets, you may need some time to get used to how they work.
The sportsbooks we recommend will match a percentage of your initial deposit. If you’re betting with cryptocurrencies, the welcome promo may be even larger than when betting with cash.
Betting Markets
Betting markets are especially important when deciding which sportsbook for MLB props. This is because they are so creative, there is no standard set of bets that you will find across all sportsbooks.
Each one will have its own unique inventory. This is another reason to sign up at more than one sportsbook so that you can have a much larger collection of bets to choose from.
Competitive Odds
In the realm of sports betting, securing competitive odds is paramount to optimizing potential returns. Whether you’re immersing yourself in the excitement of the All-Star Game or the nail-biting drama of the Fall Classic, favorable odds can significantly influence your betting outcomes.
Reputable sportsbooks recognize the significance of offering competitive odds across a diverse spectrum of events, ranging from the inaugural matchups of Opening Day to the pivotal showdowns of the League Championship Series and the ultimate quest for the World Series Championship. By meticulously scrutinizing odds for renowned teams such as the New York Yankees and the Los Angeles Angels, astute bettors can discern value and capitalize on lucrative betting opportunities throughout the exhilarating MLB season.
Quality Betting App
In today’s digital landscape, a top-tier betting app serves as an indispensable tool for optimizing convenience and enriching the overall betting journey. Whether you’re on the move or indulging in the spectacle of the game from the sanctuary of your abode, a robust betting app empowers you to place bets on your favored MLB Teams effortlessly. Seek out features such as user-friendly interface, secure payment gateways, and real-time updates on odds for marquee events like the World Series Title and the hunt for the coveted Series MVP.
With a superior betting app at your fingertips, you can stay seamlessly connected to the pulse of the action and make well-informed decisions, whether you’re backing the Cincinnati Reds or the Minnesota Twins, ensuring a gratifying and immersive betting experience from inception to fruition.
Customer Service
While we do not expect to run into problems with these sportsbooks, it is normal to sometimes be confused or need a bit of help. Sometimes we cannot find a certain market or want to know which payout methods are available.
It is very important to have great customer service representatives to help us when we need it. The best sites will have some of the following customer service options:
- Live chat
- Phone
- FAQs
Sports Betting Sites